Charles' opening headlined remark – ‘You’ve heard of Steven Spurrier’s 1972 Judgment of Paris, which pitted top California reds against the greatest clarets’ – sets him out as an man of vision as the famous tasting was actually held in 1976.
I know from comments on Tom Cannavan’s wine-pages that Wine Report is popular and esteemed. However, I have always thought that producing a newsy report in the era of the internet is rather like trying to consume soup with a fork, especially as the deadline is months before the publication date. Inevitably and through no fault of his own Charles’ news is now old. The alliance between Pierre Chainier and Caves de la Loire that created Loire Propriétés ended in January/early February 2008. Grands Chais de France took over Sauvion & Fils and Château du Cléray in November 2007 and the Pays Nantais (Muscadet and the Fiefs Vendeens) joined Interloire on 1st January this year.
The most useful section is the 10 most exciting or unusual finds. Among Charles’ selection includes a Pinot Gris VDP from Muscadet producers Bonnet-Huteau, the Touraine Amboise Becarré 2006 from the impressive Damien Delecheneau and a Pinot Noir Blanc (vinified in white) by Alphonse Mellot.
Tom’s formula of having a series of top 10s – the greatest wine producers, fastest improving producers, new and up and coming producers, best value producers, most colourfully attired producers and best bargain I find artificial. It must be particularly difficult for David Furer, who is the regional specialist for Luxembourg, as the country apparently only has around 50 producers for 1300 hectares. Clearly he is allowed some leeway as there are only 9 ‘fastest improving producers’ and 9 ‘new up and coming’ ones.