Awards and citations:


1997: Le Prix du Champagne Lanson Noble Cuvée Award for investigations into Champagne for the Millennium investment scams

2001: Le Prix Champagne Lanson Ivory Award for investdrinks.org

2011: Vindic d'Or MMXI – 'Meilleur blog anti-1855'

2011: Robert M. Parker, Jnr: ‘This blogger...’:

2012: Born Digital Wine Awards: No Pay No Jay – best investigative wine story

2012: International Wine Challenge – Personality of the Year Award




Showing posts with label 2007 Carruades de Lafite. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2007 Carruades de Lafite. Show all posts

Sunday, 23 October 2011

Is Café de la Paix supplied by 1855?

2005 Epineuil, Domaine JC Michaut

Overnight stop in Troyes on our way back from Varese. Had very enjoyable dinner at the Café de la Paix, 58 Avenue Général de Gaulle. We shared a dozen oysters then CRM had the mussels, while I had rognons de veau in a white Port sauce.

Looking at the wine list I was intrigued by the 1999 Carruades de Lafite 'Lafite de Rothschild' listed with no price but said to be 'bientôt disponible'. Perhaps this fine brasserie is also waiting for a delivery from 1855?

In the absence of the 1999 Carruades we drank a bottle of the 2005 Bourgogne Epineuil (red) from Domaine JC Michaut. This is one of the wines from the Yonne region – the reds being made from Pinot Noir. The 2005 was typically light in colour but had some weight and spice and was an agreeable easy drinking wine. There were also some Irancys on the list but we chose the Michaut as we had never drunk an Epineuil before and with a 2005 there was a chance that the Pinot Noir had ripened in this vintage.

The Café de la Paix was lively and friendly. We got chatting to a charming and very friendly retired French couple and it was interesting to hear their views on wines. Firstly that the local reds from the Yonne were too weak and acid. Proper Burgundy came from the Côte d'Or and needed at least 13% alcohol – the Epineuil was marked 12.5%. The Loire produces some attractive little wines – we didn't entirely agree here but didn't push it too hard! Beaujolais Nouveau was rubbish and that much of the ordinary Beaujolais vineyards would disappear leaving only the northern sector with the crus. South West France is now producing some good, strong wines.

They also said that there was a wine shop in Troyes where they could buy a range of wines from outside Europe, which were often good value. They had visited California and the Napa Valley and were impressed with the wines from there.

Wednesday, 16 February 2011

1855: 'a bunga-bunga, manaña company' – tale of 24b Carruades de Lafite

Château Lafite

This is a tale of Mr B, who ordered 24 bottles (two cases) of 2007 Carruades de Lafite en primeur from 1855. These should have been delivered in June/July 2010. Instead he has received a series of emails (see below) apologising for the delays and promising that the wines will soon be with him.   

Herewith are three emails from 1855's customer relations each with different delivery dates – 30th November 2010 (the supplying process will spread till the end of december), 13th December 2010 (until the end of January) 14th February 2011 (first few months of 2011).

On 30 Nov 2010, at 10:42, ludivinesb@1855.com wrote:
Dear sir,

We would like to apologize once more for this too long delivery delay.

Nevertheless, we confirm that the last references of your order will
get to us, but the supplying process will spread till the end of
december.

We will make sure that you get a notification as soon as the
remainder of your order is available on our platform.

We deplore this situation and we are making everything we can to
close this matter as quickly as possible.

We remain at your disposal for further questions.

Best regards,

_________________________________

1855
Le plus grand choix de vins sur Internet
http://www.1855.com

10, rue des Moulins - 75001 Paris, France
Tel : +33 (1) 42 61 18 55
Fax : +33 (1) 42 61 18 31
_________________________________

Ludivine Stalla Bourdillon
Chargée de Relation Client

1855
Le plus grand choix de vins sur Internet
http://www.1855.com

10, rue des Moulins - 75001 Paris, France
Tel : +33 (1) 42 61 18 55

_________________________________

**
Le 13/12/2010 09:15:59, « Mr B a écrit :

Hi you promised final delivery by the end of this month - can you
confirm this is correct please and that you have ALL the wine in your
warehouse?
Also can you tell me the date of dispatch?
** 
From: matthieu@1855.com
Date: 13 December 2010 23:54:51 GMT
To: ***
 Subject: Re : delivery by decembber 2010


Dear sir,

Thank you for your email.

We will do our best to deliver the wines before the end of december but it might spread until the end of January.
We will get back to you when the wines are available to organize their delivery.


We sincerely apologise for the delays.

Best regards,

_________________________________

Matthieu Ortalda
Chargé de Relation Client

1855
Le plus grand choix de vins sur Internet
http://www.1855.com

10, rue des Moulins - 75001 Paris, France
Tel : +33 (0)1 42 61 18 55
Fax : +33 (0)1 42 61 18 31


Date: 14 February 2011 22:17:42 GMT
To: "***>
Subject: 1855 / Follow-up of your Primeur Order

Dear customer,

Thank you for your message.
We would like to apologize once again for the important delivery delay.

As you may have noticed, our platform has been lately overloaded by the holidays' deliveries, and our suppliers' end of year break kept us from coming to terms with the deliveries of your Futures as we hoped we would do a few months ago.

Nevertheless, we wish to let you know that we are in the process of conveying the last items of your order over to our platform although this will spread over the first few months of 2011.

We will make sure you receive a message as soon as the remainder of your order is available.

We are aware of the inconvenience generated by these important delays and successive postponings.

Be assured that we deplore the situation as we are doing everything we can to close the matter as fast as possible.

We remain at your diposal (sic) for further questions.

Best regards,


_________________________________

Matthieu Ortalda
Chargé de Relation Client

1855
Le plus grand choix de vins sur Internet
http://www.1855.com

10, rue des Moulins - 75001 Paris, France
Tel : +33 (0)1 42 61 18 55
Fax : +33 (0)1 42 61 18 31
_________________________________

Matthieu Ortalda
Chargé de Relation Client

1855
Le plus grand choix de vins sur Internet
http://www.1855.com

10, rue des Moulins - 75001 Paris, France
Tel : +33 (0)1 42 61 18 55


**


'As you may have noticed, our platform has been lately overloaded by the holidays' deliveries, and our suppliers' end of year break kept us from coming to terms with the deliveries of your Futures as we hoped we would do a few months ago.' 

Matthieu Ortalda's lame excuse of 14.2.2011 would be hilarious if Mr B hadn't paid in good faith 885,60€ for his 24 bottles of 2007 Carruades de Lafite. 

Rather than the entirely unexpected arrival of Christmas I suggest that there is a more compelling reason why Mr B has not received his 2007 Carruades de Lafite – 1855 never placed an order for this wine. Instead 1855, run by Fabien Hyon and Emeric Sauty de Chalon, trousered Mr B's 885.60 euros (442.80€ a case) either with the intention that they would buy the Carruades when it was released or, possibly, never intending to supply. 

It is surely reasonable to conclude from the above exchange of emails that 1855 does not have Mr B's 2007 Carruades de Lafite. Hardly a surprise as to buy those two cases of 2007 Carruades would cost now cost 8868 € (4434 € a case) – just over 10 times what Mr B paid!

Sadly suspect that Mr B will be receiving a series of 'manaña' emails from 1855 – truly a 'bunga-bunga, manaña' companybut one which, apparently, complies with FEVAD's strict rules.