A personal view from Project consultant Sam Harrop MW
Read on.....
Standing up in front of your most highly qualified contemporaries and inviting criticism of your work takes a lot of backbone. But that is exactly what Harrop did at the IMW Cabernet Franc tasting on 2nd October 2008. His pizzazz paid off and the Project, the Ambassador wines and Cabernet Franc, were roundly praised.
‘I think this is a very good Project. The wines we tasted are wonderfully approachable. They have lost the old rusticity and are more refined. They demonstrate better wine making,’ said author, Rosemary George MW. Liz Robertson MW, consultant, agreed. ‘I was astonished and thrilled by the purity of the fruit in these wines. It proves that the herbaceous flavours do not have to be there.’
I'm certainly not an expert when it comes to this 'project' but it seems to me that the last thing I'd be likely to enjoy is a wine made according to a 'protocol' devised by an MW and intended to take a wine and make it 'export friendly.' This just smacks of commercialism and soullessness. Maybe I'm wrong....
ReplyDeleteAnon. I understand your doubts and shared some of them at the start of this project. However having tasted the results on a number of occasions, I think this project has been positive. It has encouraged growers to exchange ideas and Sam Harrop has encouraged producers not to rush in and pick when the fruit isn't properly ripe.
ReplyDeleteThere is nothing in the protocol that the best producers have not long been doing.